Shane Gillis, one of the hottest names in comedy right now, recently found himself in an awkward situation with none other than legendary Alabama head coach Nick Saban. Known for his no-nonsense demeanor and laser focus on football, Saban is not exactly famous for having a playful sense of humor—something Gillis learned the hard way during a live ESPN College GameDay segment in South Bend.
The scenario had all the makings of a combustible encounter. Gillis, a die-hard sports fan and stand-up comedian, was invited to join the GameDay crew, including Saban, for a spirited discussion ahead of the Notre Dame-Ohio State showdown. Things took a turn when Gillis cracked jokes about the SEC’s historical dominance in college football, attributing much of their success to “paying players under the table” before NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) deals became legal. He suggested, in jest, that the gap between the SEC and other conferences had shrunk now that everyone could play by the same financial rules.
Saban, a man who thrives on discipline and takes his program’s reputation seriously, was reportedly not amused. While Gillis delivered his jokes with the casual flair that has made him a comedy powerhouse, Saban’s reaction was anything but lighthearted. According to Gillis, the coach’s irritation was palpable, creating an atmosphere of tension that viewers at home might not have picked up on.
The Setup
Speaking on the Talks of the Townn podcast, Gillis recounted the incident, revealing how his fellow GameDay panelists Pat McAfee and Kirk Herbstreit had set him up for disaster. “They told me, ‘Nick’s got a great sense of humor,’” Gillis shared, laughing at the memory. “They completely tricked me. I thought, ‘Oh, this guy’s going to love the jokes.’”
The comedian said he trusted McAfee and Herbstreit’s assurances, going in full throttle with his playful digs. However, as soon as the words left his mouth, he realized Saban was less than thrilled. “The second I said it, I could feel the temperature drop,” Gillis said. “Saban just gave me that death stare he probably saves for players who miss a block.”
The Fallout
Gillis explained that the situation escalated behind the scenes, with Saban allegedly expressing his displeasure once the cameras were off. “He wasn’t just annoyed—he was furious,” Gillis said. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen someone that mad over a joke. It was like I’d insulted his entire legacy.”
Adding to the hilarity—and the awkwardness—was how the segment ended. As the set cleared, Saban was left standing alone, waiting to step down from the elevated platform. Gillis, the same man who had just poked fun at the coach, found himself as the only person around to assist him. “It was just me and Saban at the end,” Gillis recalled. “Here I am, holding out my hand to help him down, and he’s just glaring at me. I thought he was going to push me off the stage.”
McAfee and Herbstreit’s Role
Gillis didn’t let McAfee and Herbstreit off the hook. He pointed out how they had encouraged him to go all-in on the jokes, knowing full well that Saban wasn’t one to appreciate such humor. “Those guys set me up, no doubt,” Gillis said, shaking his head. “Pat was laughing so hard when Saban started fuming. They knew exactly what they were doing.”
McAfee, known for his own brand of brash commentary, has yet to publicly address the prank, but insiders say he found the entire situation hilarious. Herbstreit, meanwhile, reportedly tried to smooth things over, though it did little to change Saban’s mood.
RELATED: Nick Saban Responds to Shane Gillis’ Joke That Caused Awkward ‘College GameDay’ Moment
A Lesson Learned
For Gillis, the encounter was a memorable—and slightly traumatic—experience. “I’ve bombed before in comedy clubs, but this was something else,” he joked. “I don’t think I’ll ever recover from being stared down by Nick Saban.”
Despite the tension, the story has quickly become a fan favorite, with clips of the incident circulating widely on TikTok and other social media platforms. Fans are calling it one of the most entertaining College GameDay segments in recent memory, thanks largely to Gillis’s willingness to share the behind-the-scenes drama.
As for Saban, it’s unlikely he’ll be rushing to invite Gillis back anytime soon. The coach remains focused on leading Alabama to yet another championship, proving once again that football—not comedy—is his true domain.
Leave a Reply